‘ . 9‘“!le uninhiui
to» .‘tll‘1lit‘
iliitiwufihtng
U... i‘
lunolrmpnruhi» lump» would It'-
orwltlu outrun to tho petitioner. A Jill)“
or thittnttnurt utiltiilhe till , toll
PM“ WWW .
tho court for it order or intimation.
then only where hill orderniittit outta
into it I ioeliiegu in will upon “it
’ihl Judge tllllkmfli
than
.‘.9 H" il-
x #5 Yul: ,.
i
Weill ”W
1‘ ‘ alssiu’s WW"
tillllfllt;;lliflllllllilt
italictil Chums lit two impor-
ta’m laws Urged.
M
u
{Wmmm'b Jun. 7,—Preatdent Tuft
“lit to congremx the following lipeellll
nl‘a'u'a'go’ on the proposed ttinendtneuis
to m. interstate mmutoree rind unlit
_ titu‘lt tum:
..T‘t) illuminate and House of Represent-
wrest
i beg to submit to you eertulu retrain.
menddllom no to the unieudiuents to
the interstate enmniorre low and cer-
‘mtnsconttiderutionu itrlqlug out of the
operations of the untitrust tuw sug-
gesting the wittdom of federal lover-
pot-utiou or industrial eotupnuieu.
inter-late Commarco Law.
In the unuuul report of the interstate.
commerce (-oruuilsaiou for the year titliti
attention bl culled to the fuel tbut be-
tween July i. littlti. unit the elnue of
that your ultileen suits bud been begun
to set name orders of the (‘Oltltltlttrtioll
‘7(beniiieu one. l'Olllllit‘lH‘i’t] before that
A".
"‘0‘
' emu-«an lllt'lt
i'ntei and thin i‘ew nrderu ol’ mot-h
istttttmllt‘e litltl been permitted to go
Dmgvout protest. in twelve of the
and “referred to. it “'an plated. pre-
und fill” injunctions were prayed for,
mlwmm-anted in six utid refused ill nix.
been uiot'ee every carrier ufi‘et'led by
The omciutile commission into it run.
waulk gttvtllt to llppettl to u ledt-rlll
morning than»: it from the enforce-
”1ileut of tilt order which it may show
to be ptitna i'ttt'le trolillseulnry or an»
instiy diset‘llnltlnlory in its effect, and
[a thin tipplleutlou uniy he nuide to it
court in any lllsil'it't or the boiled
~8tntea ttot only does delay result in
the enforcement or the mill-r. but
great utieertutntt- is ruined by eontru
Not! of decision. it would not be
proper to attempt to deprive on) (tor-
perutlon of the right to the review by
:1 court of any order or deerei- which.
I! undisturbed. would rub it oi u l‘l‘ll‘
Ionlltle' return ttpou its investment or
"Would subject it to burdens which
Would unjustly discriminate ttmlillfll it
lull in favor ol‘ other eurrlers similar-
I! situated. Wind in. however. of In»
prelim importance ht lliut the duciition
ht'lucli questions «bull be no speedy
‘II the nature of the elreunmtuueeu
Will admit and iliut u ulilt’ot-niity or
lecithin be secured.
For till: purpose i recommend the
flamblfahmeut of u court oi the United
flute! composed of live judges dentu-
“M“1ttI'intit'li purpose trout union:
“to circuit Judges of tho United liiuteii.
to be knowu in; the "United States
'90an of commerce." which court shall
he clothed with ext-lintive orlgliiltt juris-
diction over the following elutiiteit of
«Ion:
“flout—Ail roses for tile euioreeuu-nt.
otherwioll'thnu by ttdtuilii-ntlon untl
collecfion of a forfeiture or iii-nutty or
brlnfllctlon of criminal putih-iltitieut. of
Intafot‘d‘er of tilt; ltiterotitlu t‘uluitltti‘tft'
dommtnlou other than (or the payment
of money.
”undo-Alt canon brought to enjoin.
latitude. admit or Millpond any order
or Monument or the immune cunt
. mutton" oumuiluton.
Third—All lint-h cult-it its outlet nee-
, on 3 01- the lit?! 0! Feb. iii. 1003.
{down Ill tho "itikhui net," are utt-
’ 6 to ho unliniitlttod in it elreull
" ‘0? fit. Utllttld lithium.
tiiuttdttliittti pro»
m in under the pruvhilotui ol
position 20 or tttirlit’iti 2;; ol tho utter-
{ditto hammer“ law ttr‘o authorized to
‘Whtttld in it ctl'otlit court or tho
’ ' “Ilium.“ “
WWW to provide it Inuit-tout aunt
Migfijudm to tumble tithi,coitri to
armoured. it will no litlct‘flittll'y to
Authoring the appointment or live out
‘tliliio‘tiul circuit Judson. Annual ironi-
Wilton of “0.000 should be pro-
\
,. M Q; the tutti-onto court.
‘ fitting "MI? nations of tool: court
m in tutti in the capitol. not It
W powwow-roll to until trunnion:
. um: putt-iii or ill. Unite-it titula-
. f ’ dulrflbil. Ind it! untur- tltld
in mm in mum hunt. lino
“tool! to review by the momma
m it! tho Untied lIiMOflrwmt the
W that tint commit at tho do
- mm m chill not he mm
W tho mm mm tittiltt In or“
W“ {hi ileum court mount no
‘ ‘ tutti intention to rennin
~ intimation“. thtlhd i is tightrope.
thereto. that such trropur the (tuition
would remit to the petitioner. specify-
ing the aurora of the damage.
7 Under the painting low tho. litton‘
aniline-coupon"!!! mkltt‘tittiliuti high! hv
lilateo gold iltiteudu litigation in the
"Nahum i‘or tho) util'oreetuoutor in the
defense or it: under: and deemed.
lti my opinion. nil litigation «fleeting
tho novel-tuition should be under the
dlroct control of the department at
jitltllcli. ,‘
Ant-«mom on Rum.
. (Rite subject of ligroeuteutt-i between
cprriern with respect to rules bun been
often discussed in Pililflrl‘fl‘l. Pooling
arrangements and utiroeinentti were
condemned by the pent-rill lieutttttont
of the people. mill under the, Sherman
antitrust law any ugreemetti bet ween
rurrit-ru operating in t‘evtrulnt of inter-
tltnte or international trade or eotu-
lnel‘ee would be unlawful. I tree no
reason why ugreenioutn between eur-
rleru subjevl to the net. opal-trying the
elnniillleiitlonit of freight utid the rules,
litre» llud eilttt‘izes for transportation of
pituiieuuern und freight wliieh they mny
nilt‘ee to establish nhotiid not be per!
tallied. provided roplex of illicit our—it»
moms be promptly tiled with theI rout»
tulsulnn. bill nutrient to all the pro-
visions of the iiitet'ulule emittueree net
and subject to the right of any portion
to titllt‘t’l ugreenwut to moral it tilt to
:ill or ntt)‘ of the um‘eed t‘lttell. fares.
viuirueii or eliiusilit-uiluiin iiv thirty
tlttt‘e’ tltitit‘e In writing to the utltet‘
lt'tt'lii'n null lo‘tlie eolnuilsuiuu.
Min-ti mniplutui in mode by ntilppern
over the route or the low under whieb
they tire held bound to know theI ingot
rule tlpplieuiile to titty pt'opiwed ltllip-
ttietil without. tut u mutter of (not.
boring any t‘Pt‘lllill tut-unit of humility
useet‘iuipiliu R\li‘i‘l rule. l tiiililt tlitti
the Inn ninuild ptmitle that u l‘lii‘l‘it'l‘.
upon written rmptenl it; hit intending
~iilppet, siiiiltitl tilt-tie In urliilit: iilt'
rule or eilarge upplleuble to the line
potted ultlpinetil tinder tiny It‘hl’dtlit'l‘
or tarii’lu to willeli MINI enrrler til it
thirty and ttutt if the party limiting
~itu'b implexl i-iinll «lll'fer duttlttue In
t‘llllfif‘tlill‘lii't‘ of Minor rennet! or nitrite
\‘itlll It.) tilluiil' lill‘ pt‘tttii'l‘ i‘ille lit” in (flut-
~etpietiee of :l niluslitteittent of the rule
iilt' i'nl'rit'l‘ shrill lie llriitie to n petitilifi‘
in some renamiulde ntnottnl. mi)‘ 32:30.
to lieerne in the litiltetl Mull-it nod to
bo l‘l‘l‘ttl‘t‘l‘l'ti lti ll rlvll ill-lion brought
it} lilt‘ liltill‘iliii'iitie ‘Ii‘lrit'i liltlil‘til-y,
limit-r thou-slitting law the t‘tillllllil'
stun l‘lill lit-l only with l‘eiqim't to un
itiil'tzl‘tl oil-outlive rule or unduly din
t‘l‘illlillflttil‘y prtiellt'e by it ehrrIt-r on u
l‘lllltlliililli ulnde by Fttlllt‘ llltliiiiltlnl
iiiTt-oted tin-retry 1 tree no reason why
the (‘itllllllihntttli iihotild not be author-
ized to act on llit own initiative till
Well hit upon the l‘tilliltiililll‘ oi tin
iiitilvldltul uiid tlitzii tlint llie min
intuition ultuli be fully empowered he
youd nit) lltlt‘fillttll lo [llINH upon the
I'illfl‘iiiit‘itlittilt‘ ul t-nltilnotiitieti tor pur
potion ill lixing l‘ttll'tt, in illn- nutnuet
till it may now do with i'i-ttpt-vl to it‘lll
illii\llllll|il rule nppllt-nlile loitlii li'tlilii
[Nlruuitifl
Public Pay; incruud Rain.
Under the Milling low the twiiinilt
:dutl Iltll)’ not inveiilipnle nu int-reuse
ltt ruluo until ufler it nihtii tune be
mine ell‘el-llw
'lie t‘tllttlllikbillli ~liitil lil-iitt' nu mill-t
hinting ibut nu vhlalitlu rule in net-us
tve ultd tilt‘el'iiliu it to tie retitieett lilo
i'iii‘l'it‘l' :tfl‘l-t'tt-d unit by pt‘tut-t-ttltt :71 its
the t'tllll‘tt‘ ntu)‘ the operation of Ntli‘h
order or t‘t‘tillt'tittll tor ttmntim null
ell-u ,ienru it IlliN lhereloie been out;
nested tlnit the t‘liiltlttittillltlt hilttttiti
bu I‘ililttht‘l'l'ti. \t‘ileitt-ter ll proposed
inert-tine tn ruteii iii tiled. nl out t' to en
ter tlpuli uh luvenlipilltoii of the red
uttlnlliielieun of tile itit‘l'eillte unit to
limit» on order postponing llluetlt-ellve
titlit.‘ oi itut'li int-reuse ttlilil ul‘lt-i' web
iltt't'tttlitxltliltti «hull he completed.
To this lunch obit-etion hint been
tuiidu on the purl oi eitrilerit The)
eontrtnt lttul thht would be. lit eti‘eet.
to tutu.- ttoni the outlet-ii ol' the roll:
rontltl lilo tuituugenieut ot lhoit prop
t‘t'iiutt nod to eiotilt' lin- inletulitlo will»
inureueoitinilmdon with the original rate
limiting power. it pulley which With
tnuell dinetttllteil til the time ot‘ the pint
tome ol the ltepbiiia not iii lllttritt nail
whit-b watt then and hail uiwiiyu neon
illnllnetl)‘ l‘ojlieit'll.
They point to the prm-lulou oi the th
it'l‘ltltiit: roman-roe not providing rot
ruttlitilthitt to the t‘itfllllt'l’p ht i-ttrriurn
of uttemtlire riltetl elutruell lit whim
where the tlt‘tit't' oi the l'iiittlltii-iuiltlt i‘t‘
ilnuinu tint-h rule-ii tire llllli'lltt‘tl. it
may ho doubted how ell’eetive thin
reiiiotiy reutly in. listiei'ieiiett tutti
shown thiit utility. pertinpii lllmtl. tittlp
purn do not resort to tti'ut.‘lttltiiltt;tt to
l'eeovur “ltd otteeuttlve rnlou whit-ii the}
may hurt: been rettlured lo pity. for
the tdtupiu mount that they burn tutti
ltd tin.- viilotl hold to tho cold or the
good:- not] tlilllt enhanced the prion
that-eat to their ritutotttent and tliiii
the public hits in tilt'tirl hold the bill.
tmpoutblo to donut-vi» Tariffs.
On the other hunt. the enortliuun vol
limit or trlilntporhiiiou rind-poo, pin
grout number of iii-puttin- lurid: tiled
annually with the intention minaret-er
Mittiflitfl‘t. itiiiounlliitt to utmost 2W.
littl).«itiut'ttiu ttittnmlttlltty or our eon;-
tltilfllttt littpeiwiiilhii the nnttittin ut
tot-tint iii milliliter of tidbit lit-minim:
admire on every imtlllmfltllkm title
within the Unload throat to the extant
~‘: mwittltor on ‘irotnptutut oral it: own:
‘ intuition: to outorttponuu illit‘Mflfilflmt
lulu titr
Up the olitei “and. ti,
‘. . ritttiu will. libido-lit
\ . manottpblrum of ltilt‘i choline
fid‘fllili it. till further hippo ; in
Jlb’t dim-retlun‘ to polltponli the itii'oottvof
ditto of such i‘ujiutouoii thorium tor. ti-
pinion itM,lIt‘Witifl nutty» d'uyrbe
rplitl tint data when intuit ruin would
into effect. it” within intuition it
until detenniiio that tuloh incl-outta hi
nuwiiuonuble it may then by tilt order
either forbid the int-reuse tit till or
tilt the mitxllutitu‘ beyond which it
tittiill not he until . it. on the othor
inuid. at tho exhalation of tliill tltne
tho commission ihnll not have mut-
plotedt-ltiu inveittlzulloit. then the rate‘
tilttlll lflklt adopt preelttelv till it would
under the t'XillNlll: htw. and that emit-
mtatiton inn: ohuttuue‘itn investigation.
‘Shippcr to Have that" of ”out...
i know of no rettnon why ‘0 tibippiir
ohoolil not have the rtulit to elect be
tween two or more mtnbllshed through
mitten. Stilljfi‘l. however. ill the oxen
also of thi‘a right to such rrhfiilltflilie
rounlutlouu til lilo Iniertttalo cotnmereo
t‘Olillilitli‘liiill liuty prelim-the.
i reoituluitiud illiti the low lthttil htt
iitnehdetl tut ill! to provide ibnl from
litid litter the tlnie of it! pliuvtulo no
rulirond rmupuny oubieet to the tutor.
utute eoiiiuuvree net aliutl. tiii‘l'f‘lLl‘ or
ltutll‘peliy. ut-ipitre our interest! of any
trim! in eupitui Mock or pttrt-luine or
ienne illi_\' rtiiirouti of titty other rorpo-
rutlou with-h t‘tlttilttflt‘ll with it reupeietr
lug Illiflittt‘flfl in whirli the lulernlnto
(‘tttttmtli‘t'tt net ttpplihit lint exptn‘tnlly
tor the promotion or line lniuoritv stortt-
luitllerti lu went-lug in ‘tlwiu the bent
tunrltel for their «loci; i reroiuntend
thiit uiirh prohibition be coupled with
ii provloo that it nitnli not operate to
irevenl nay eorpnrution whirl! at the
note ol‘ the thiamine of linen not till!"
t‘VII not limit llniu one-hull of lhl' t‘tr
tire horned lint] niiltttiinillut: eupitnt
Hiltl‘k of tiny other rulirttiid rntnpliny
trout ot-tiitigtliu till or the multiplier of
melt Stork nor to prohibit tiny rilllrt‘itttt
tottiphhv whit-h at the time of the Ni
flflim‘ill of the in w lit epenitluu it rnll
mud of our other i‘tii‘ltiirlliittll nutter
tense. “Xi‘i‘tlit‘tl for n term «it not to.“
thrill twenty‘llve yearn, from ueiplltim:
lite fi'\‘('i'fliltl'lltl“\' litt’llt‘i'iilill it! the tie
mined ruliroitd. but tluil snub prtwl
militia tiliitll not operate to :illtiirirlxe or
Multiple the iteiplt-dilou titl‘lillL'it uttu‘li
Ittl‘llt‘l‘xilill or otiierwiw. of it mouth!
in: line or inlet-mil therein in violation
of the ttttti-trtt-«t or our other low
"Wltnrinc" oi Hallrott' dtotk.
l t‘eeoinineltd the enactment til it inu-
providing llttit no rttllrotld i-urporuilnu
oilidl‘et to the iiilt‘rsliile mutton-roe zit-l
*iiittii ltereut'tvr for tiny purtmtte eon
buried with or tripling to itit)’ purl oi
iii inbuilt?“ got‘ltt‘lit‘tl by mild uri tuition
:iuy mpitul ntoflt without previouu oi
simultaneous purulent to it of not ion
than the par value of illicit otiwli or on)
bonds or other oblbzulions lexuept notm
illuiitrltlg ltul tilol‘t‘ limit lttw veal {tutti
the date it! their tunnel without lite
|ii‘t‘\illlll| or Hitlltllinnwitto plum-ill ii-
“Wit corporation of not lentil thou the
pur l'tlitle oi Nllt‘il bonds or other obit
xtiliotiu. or. if mulled ni term than then
par value. then not without «in-h pug
input of litt' l't-iluoiinlilr toirliel \liilll‘
uf mil-ll tmmln oi "inland-ma no mumr
illilll‘tl It) iltt’i illit'i'tidll‘ ttllllltlt‘rt t-ruitt
tillmloll. nittl liitli tin property netv‘ii'et
or other tlillti: limb initiwt lilinli it‘
lukell iii |lll§lllvill to «Hell llirlit't enl
potrlliou of the put ot “Hit-r required
wire of titli'ii Sil'tit. liuitnl til other oil
ilgutltitt eteept sit the l‘:tll tuiite ill
‘Ut‘h property M'llit‘l‘.‘ or uttiet thine
tut lltti‘t'l‘ittiltt'ti "i tlit- outiiitiiwlou. unit
lliail uitt’ii m'l elwl .ilm t‘ltlililiil pruvi
\ltllt!‘ to prevent Htt‘ plume it} the till
pt‘uvtlli-llt til' Illtllitlllt‘l bistro or notes
nurturing hi it iwrimt not ext-mini:
twelve itumlim from dole in until tuuu
nor an to minted the muiuuuinti to the
tlppl‘oitil of it illi‘At‘r nunmut or flock in
Mouth! lti llrtlt‘t‘ in t‘illl'e lolt‘lt union
than ttliotilil it‘ullilltiiit‘i) limo bum re
.ptlt'ed
Sileh net should aim) ttl‘in‘tdc ior mp
.lll'lNM‘iti lit the titleitilitle emiitnum-
~‘ttlitttlilltiitlil of the non-uni ol' Itottl
.ttttl titttliltt to lie limited it) pity t‘ltilrttutl
t‘tllltlttllty itiitileel to this iiet upon an)
tt'dfmiliiitlllitlll puntunnt to Jilllil‘iltl tulle
or other it'itul llrtlt‘l‘t‘t‘illult in order ill
prevent the home of Itoeh and bond!-
to tilt numunt lu ”Wait at the full
mine of the propirty \tiiielt in tile Ittlh
tool of utirh tit-timiniitulion.
Ill itdditlon to the foregoing mound
input» of the liilerillute ooltiuwree low.
the ititeriitute (:Ullllllt'l't’t' t-iiitillllutiioti
oittilliil be given the putter. iii'lur in
hearing. to deterittllie upon the uni
itil‘tll t'tillttll‘ttt'lllltt oi tliime uppilniletin
titttld by the liiiloineu iii the animation
of lrtltuil tho defects iiittl lat-it at uni»
identity in phleh live out to produce
'll'dltll‘ttll uitd littilrieu to rultwuy lrulie
niuu.
‘t‘lie iplenlloh inu- itl‘it‘t’l‘l in the noon
ntiuu of tint inlernlnt'tl t-otnuturue out
pitivel-it‘ llnblllty urt full to btt‘lit'tllt"
unit win he brought 'ituultutt the not
longer compile) In tiny plueu other
tinin that or its home other. l‘rurotts
ltl melt unit should he t‘tflflt'it’llii! «er
in it upon tho uluiiou intent oi the
emotion}; upon ‘Willtttt Wt‘i‘t‘tt‘t‘ hi till
thorium to be tlhttie in ordiuury It"
lions ltl'ittiit’fl tintillr ilttlte tum.
Antlttrutt Law and Fuller-t harm»
lion. ., ,
The laureate to tilt- eopltttl of u but
until for tho ourpute tit rodtleihu the
out tit til‘tttMt‘ltttlt and «timing item
only lit the tittiortiieimuu tutti tat-onto
nit wutlul .iu moth-m prion-m up the
vitamin from that tulml tool to ihtt tum
rhino, When. therewith we mm m
mil-time the onto-tat tit within!“ in
ndtipiittu m to mild! “Blitlt‘mtttt m
trout net“ it) into. wilt-M: lit “with“
titanium or hittnivlui itutt libido atrium
N Ii“ . .T
y in mtrulul or interrupt! or
twain! ii I «intuit-tip it. out
to ludictntrtli idol restraint hykiiiilllno‘
lion and whoreh‘y in the tortilla lieu-
“titlti ovary monopoly or titlotltpt to int}
nopolltie' and. every continuation ‘ot
‘wilitllit‘tlt‘y with other omens to our
nopoiiitu titty put-t or‘lulerttlitto trade
or routinorooin nationhood unfillegnl
told initial» outlier-i to nluitiur punish-
ment or t-ottmtnu'. we intuit taller that
the evil, itintud tit was not the men
liiimtmn ot the onlorprise. bill it was
the mammalian or ounttui out! villi“
with the uxpmtu or linplioti tutti“ i0
t‘ttiiii‘tiill illii‘l‘ttil‘tlt! or foreign com.
mom or to itiotiopottzo it in whole or
iii purl. A mere lueldontitl,reslrlllut
of trude ttnd ootupodliou III not with
in the inhibition of the net.
lt 'ti possible for the owner: of it
business of tunnttrurturltix and stallion
unoful urtletoit or niureltnudlne so to
eottdttet liltl‘il' huvtuotnt lot out to via»
into the inhibitions ot’ the null-trout
low had yet to neeuro to thoniiiulveti
the betteiit of tho ocolioutluit of Mull»
uni-tnout and Df‘llt'ttiillt'litill due to the
concentration undor villi! mmit‘oi oi
largo eupilui and many ptitnlu iii
they not! no other lndneoluenl ltuin tho|
constant tow prime of their product and
it“ “PM Quality. to inflict lithium! and
their buslnm hi it pl‘otttltbitt one. they
.vlottllo no luw. lint it llioyiuuotnt‘ii it!
it into of their pri-lmtitterutiug cupilul
Mind by a solo or their good; tempo
rurily at unduly low pileup to drive
out of nutritious their eolutmlltom. or
it' they attempt by exclusive central-ls
with their pulronu und liirolttn of note
dealing etteept upon linen eontrmrtii
or by other methods of u tiitullur char-
urlt'i‘ to one the toughness ot their rt» .
sources and tho extent ut their output
compared lvllh the total output int n
menus or eotuiwlllug ennlotu titid trlgtit-
lilting off cottttu-lttlnn. then they tint—
rlono ll purpose to restrain lrmte nod
to outithliuh it monopoly itud violate the
act. .
Economy .vOQ Only Ether of Blunt».
1 wittli to white thni distinction no
oniphatic it: pimllitti. intention i cote
rrlvo that nothing mold tuippou more
deutrut'lit‘e to the proopertty ot this
country thou the limit ol thul grout
umnotny in {-ll'lltllil‘iitlu whteh butt been '
and will be eil‘ei'ml in all tnuutttiii-liio
lug: linen by tho etuptogtiient or large
capital under one itutnngetui'ut. i do
out menu to on: itistl there to not it
innit bermul wittvh tile eenuoiny ol
itinliugetiioni by the enlargement o!"
piuut t‘l‘fli‘t‘il. iiinl whore this huppeutl
Mid (‘ttulltilttiiltttl 1‘0"”!!th littyiinil lllltt
point the very flirt shows intent to
giioitiumilxe uml not to economize.
The null-trim alulule «was painted in
mm. and pmuemtmim were limb be»
gun under it. in tile rune of the
[foiled Sittil‘fl let‘ktiu liltigiil. ktltitt‘ti till
the "sttgut ii'tttli t‘l’h‘fl‘.” boruttne of the
burrow trope u! the pleudintra titt-
combination sought to he enjoined mitt
held not to be “winded within the
ltl‘tliiillintfll ol' the not. bemoan the
.iveriuetltil dill not go beyond the liierei
.icuuittllioti oi illiltlliillt‘llll‘illfl plutitii
for the refining of Minor und did not
include that or it (“Nut and iti'lt'lltk‘ti
tutmlnt upon lrndu rind (\“flilll‘fl‘? in
the sale lititl delivery of «tight arrow
i-lule tinuudtirteu tilid in toretgh lrude
The result of the nugnr trtult one will
not ililmt)‘ in than it pure other rout
punters rind moulntulllnpn melting n‘
tiniiinr method at making profit by
utilubihihiug no absolute control iltltl
monopoly in a pariteulnr line or tiltltlllu
(below it Hl'llm.‘ or tlutuuniiy uxulnxb
pmverultonu lit the teller-til jlll‘ttitilt‘r
lion. and where tlnit turbidiellou hi
burml lh rettpecl to u business willeli 3
in tieeetmurllt millilitenntlrato with the
bmludiirleii or the muntry no tilttte
prwteeutiou in little to supply the need
ed uiueliiuery {or adequate restraint or
punishment.
li‘ollowltm tho stlmtr truitt derision.
howovor. them iiuvn more filling to tho
slow hilt eortulu «turtle of tudleltil
tilitpottltlon rum involving it mtnttrtie
lion of the null-trust iiihlute und its
elimination until now they neat to
utubruee every plume. of tliiit but
which run he prtielieully presented to
the Alilurieuu public nod to the gov-
ernment for itetlon. The: show thut
the lttltbtrutlt net tutti n wide ”ope. and
npplloll to many t‘tiltlhiltnllttlls in output
i
mention. wintering them unlawful
and Itht-et to indictment and re-
limit“.
All Rutnlatn F'rhtdlhn.
The supremo Court to titlvernl or Ittt
dot-littotnt hits deettund to rend into the
“utility the word "tttirenltouuhie" be»
fore ”matron" of mute." on the around
ihilttliu sltttulii upplletl to all restraints
and doeit not intend to leuvo to the
court the distinction to determine what
in it moonuhlo restraint of triido.
The exptunidon "reittruilit oi' lrudu"
romeo front the common low. iitiil tit
eomluutt law there were vermin trove
tulliu incidental to the eut‘ryiug out or
a “III“ or principal t-otilrnet whieh
won mid to be covetlnntli in partial
routrulnt or nude and were held to he
uitfomitilo bottuiuo “t't'tllltllllllly" ntitlltt‘
ed to the performance of the ninth or
prluctpui contract. And underttio we
oral language um) by the unpreiuo
court ill several curios it tvoulll «out
that tit-on ouch inrlttoolril eorent‘luti iii
Whit or lutortttute trudo were with
iii the inhibition of the Milton- unit
uiutlt. be conditioned. to order to mold ‘
Inuit g reqult. i have thought unit mild
that “ought no wait to unload the
statute to no to uxvltttil! linen. eovw
outfit; from its euhdttuuuittuit. it cltltfl ‘.
initiation of tho lutetdreitliima ot
tilt court. boomer. «thou-ti quito elem»
I: in ovum pimutiuu the outlet olivin-
tltitt tint shell tuollleuttil retitrulltht ol
twill m ,iluid.,hiitil toil-e tlfttttlll no .1
lowland lint antimony. the neutron
“ititttolitithlii iii to until; ihii’ mt.
Willi! met or it the mutt til the re
. ‘ mm is- , , tau «timeout
l . or will .M
W for
thtwonldhmmryllmw
mile. mt" willful. hermit
t reminder and uttuewmnrv llivuninn by
', , . ‘, 'fiiiflmfl'
Itrutnt or trade held it i-otutiioa lull
to ho runaonultlo doing not exist.
The opinluint or the supreme enurt
exclude from the operutiuo or the not
t‘0ilil‘lit'ltt homing tutor-alum trudti in
but it ltuntll null ineldeutul Wit)" and
iipplv tlin illitutr only to the miller“
about) at by chairman. , ~
The lithium hit: been on the lilotuto
book now for two tirertdeti. not! the
tuiproute eourt in more then u dozen
uplnlomt bun outintrllrd It in uppihrie
lion to \‘ill‘illtllil phone: of nutritional outn-
bitiittioini nod to rei’erunre to vitriol!!!
intuit-lull matter. The value of it
statute which ill Mindemd moret titui
niore‘eet-luln in tin inclining by ii iii»
vii-it of dt't'ifiltllltt of the allpretite t-ourt
itlrunilteit tl till-ting mutton for lent-int:
the net no ii iii to ilcrutnplish ltlt ultei'lll
purpouo.
it lit the duty and the purpose of tho
ext-entire» to direct on tuveutigutlon by
the dupuruuent of Jiliillee through the
proud Jury or otherwise ltllo the bilt~
tors. ortninlznlluu utid purposes of till
tile littlinttriul companies with I'Hllwt‘l
to which there in tin renouituiile
ground for suspicion that they hurt-
been ornnnim] for n purpolw utid lire
eoiiduullug buslnelut on u ptun Wllit'il
hi Iii riolutlou oi‘ the unit-trust ill\t‘.
ilul‘ atlrll tilt lliveutilzatiou utid pilflfli-J
lilt- ltl‘lmt‘t‘uiiotl of comirntlono tvlioite
limiitwritr or limit-notion urn-en! the
«radon not only of Itoi‘ltholdero. bill
or tttilllonti or wuge euruen, employees
and intimidated tradesmen. llllltfl tlfit‘ftt- ‘
ital-iii; lend to disturb the eoutldem-e ot
the business community. to dry up the
now llnwimx noureett of enpllul from
"I plum-ii of hoarding uud produce it
hall in our present prouperity thul will .
entitle suffering and Itrnlnod t'lrt'litti»i
nluueeu uniting the blunt-mu litany tori
the fullltll of the guilty few
Pedal-ll Ohnflar Juflifiod.
”room"! in the industrial rolnbluu-i
liottit milled "tutors“ the principal tut-ii '
nets! in the sale of nit-viii in utility
Rifllt‘ll and in foreign titnrttetl --lu other
woods. the tutetmtute und foreign bind».
liens tar “needs the litll-litimtl done in
not one IUHI‘. 'I‘lilti fuel will itiwlli'v
tho tutti-ml novel-numb! in running it
federal runner to inteb ti t‘fl'l‘tilitltiiitlil_
to matte unit will in liiti-mute nod for-i
elnn million-roe the prozlueta oi titlefti‘
tuunut‘nriuro unlit-r .llil'il iiuiitnlionx M
will swore a eouiplinumi with the tutti i‘
lriixt low. it h: ttmullde so to frame It
iilntote lillli. while it often: proleetioti
to u iwlernl eotututnt nuttltmt tuimifui.
the ulsilett. ll titulll subject it to rentton
.tltle taxation and emiirol luv the platen
with renpeet to purely local itit‘illt‘Ss
Stunt pimple eoltiluetlot: grout blitzi-
noun-ii hilt-e rtn-riwhed It hope and it
belief that ill unmi- wily or other A line
hilly be drawn between "grind tritsta"
nod ”tutti trot-tilt.“ The piitilie. unit m-
perinlly iilt‘ business pubite. ought to
rid tlielliselem of the MN! llml with it
illutliielimi is prnetienliie or eziu be lit
tritdured into the slutttle l‘ertuiniv
under the prevent untitrunt law no.
«urn diminution exi-tlx it hits been
pmpmeil. however that the word "roll ‘
munitie" should be “Hill" a port of the
etatute and then that it tillonld he tell ‘
to the t‘ftlil't to any «but til it rmummblu Y
restraint of trade. what it! n rent-mutton
mppretmton of muttwtlllon whut i! it
rtmmtmble monopoly. i vl‘ltttlre to
think that this lit in put into the innit-i
or the won it power liiuumlbio to utter- l
elm» on our unpainted? prinetple.
in i‘olixtderlug iii-littlotiu of tilt“ nutt-
lruut low we might. of court-e. not in‘
rowel that llizil lnw umke- tluinwful‘
method“ of warning on bovine“ Wllit‘lt
heron- llii privatel- were regarded nti‘
evidetiee of intuition uuuut'tlv unit Mlle- ,‘
menu and lizzil they were denouneed in i
this not not homun- or their intrinsic .i
initnorolttr. but immune of the dancer .
out twullu toward wlilrh they end-vi. l
the t‘tttlt‘t‘illl‘fl'itlll of industrial power
in the illlildI or the few, lendiut: to
opprt‘ulltltt utttl Hiyhltl‘il‘t‘
Through "ll our t‘ttlltlit‘t'l‘ntiltll of ililit
uruve tittt‘tiltmt. however. we must In-
xist that the suppreeulou oi murpell
lion. the euntroliltip of prion mm the
monopoly or tilteitipl to _ll‘l('ilttl|lliii7t’ ttt
illll‘l'tilflit' Millitlt‘rt‘e null tittnllteioi tire
not only unlawful. but mntrurv tn the
public good. and that they tnnal he re.
‘tll‘llillt‘d tiltd punished ulitll hurled.
National incorporation Law.
t therefore recommend the ettiietmetil '
by minim-nit of it general liiw tin-tidbit.-
for the formation of t-ortmmtiuim in
routine in trade and cmtiluoren uniting
the «titles and with foreign national.
protet‘iltlt: tin-to truth iiutttto itiit‘i’fi‘l‘t
euee by the ninth and retiuiitllnn tilt-tr
uetivltlt-I. on till to prevent the Noun
more under utillouul attttpleei- of them
lliltlilt'l whieti have ltl’l'ltlfl nutter pinto
eoltll'ol. illicit ll inw nhtttlill provide
tor the bottle of ntoelt of ntlt'il t‘ttl‘tm-
rullunti to tilt untouul e-ptnl only to the
«1th paid in on the idol-it. uud it till-
ttloelt be ilflttl‘d for tin-pony then til it
itiir \‘ltillliiiliit. iiiietu'lttlnm tinder itp«
prltt'tll lttltl tiltpervtttioit of («lent me
thorny. lifter it full null tmlttplote lilo.
eiotture oi till tho fuels ilt‘t'ittiltlittt to
the value or lull-ll broperty and the lit-
toroiit therein of the pet-miti- in whom
it it prolioml to lmitto utmlt in put-
ment of ittelt property. it ultotlltl tutu
luv! the rent itud pot-munil lti'ntlttt‘l)‘ lttily
itl Itieh t‘ul‘pm‘lttitlliil to the mime init-
iitlou. tilt is iltllttulrll by the tituteii with»
in witlttii it may he ultuuted upon other
illitllttr properly blunted then-til. utut
it tillattld routine Iueli unrimriiltnmi to
lilo full tutti etittiptete reports- or their
opertlthniti with the department ot t-oni.
untrue tutti tithot til ri-uuliir iiilervutu
tlo‘t‘pi‘ruttoiui «mounted under thin iu-t
should he prohibited from neiilitrluu
lttltl holding; stoeit iii nlltttr titrt'ltttt‘ltlittlt!
thxl‘tllll for npeelul pronoun upon up»
jil‘ttt‘ili hr the utilitarian-rill utiihur-
thin line! niobium tiut minor under
uutlutuil itinl’iitlutt‘ul the hunting enue
puny with unlittttl‘iuuie t'tti‘ltltfltlillitlg. lu
dltl'mnttlltttm‘ ‘iizliit'h link broth/linena
r ; iiii‘ltmmotmrr hi the flWfltttttt nt
Wvudmwmuwhe
A. .
“it“ Wt il‘ttttltl tutti tlllttitiptillt‘tl, '
ii on Whit «it u» «um
mum
out intuition ‘fiuxtu ‘ ' i
of trilde hi to tie-um. rely enrol-cud it.
[a ouuunl‘bll tttlt‘tj" the“ “”110le intrude“
mom «unit proiji‘tio for tho creation of
nutlutuu eot'iutriitiniir to rut-rt" on o
lelxltluntle‘ liltutllovn' lln-ounbou‘t‘ tilt
[lulled urtileit.’ "l'ho i-otiitli-tlug lawn of
the initial-tint miles ot the Linton with
t'eNpeet to flirt-tun eoriuirutionll built!
it dilllrtlit it not titlptmtiiblo tor on!
et‘irporullou 'to eomplv with their to
iplti‘emelrtlt llo hit to enrrr tilt Maine“
in u monitor of diftereat nifliel‘.‘ ‘
To the uttuuimlion lhut thin proposal.
of output iill‘tit‘ptil‘tltllttt tor induxmiil
mititbinttliolttt it! intended to fumi‘ltit
tlieutu refuge ltt whit-h to continue in:
dumruit situates nutter ietlurul' prom"
lluii it ttitoiitd be until that the mount
. i‘ “ ‘
. could do: At-
vorit 'Phoim at angular mm.
‘ {Stupid Sidney Erliawloyuud hit!
deputies are somewhat unrpriued iii:
the“ vohort that t the Southern New
England Telephone company lntontiti
toilhollflh rebates on tho telephones of
uto’te"0tllriailt. Mom; of mo deputies
who live in remote. parts of the coun-
ty would not have tolophonea in their
homes- unim they got it rebate and it
is thought that the company ought to
take into consideration how important
it ill that those men should be within
reach of communication.
‘l‘llil in particularly true in rural
lire i-otiteuipiutetl dons. not repenbvtlttl
sheriuuu antitrust law nod to not to
be (ruined no lit to permit the doing
of the wrong» willeit it til the purpotte
oi titut low to prevent. but only to for
let u routitiuunt-o uud udrlinee of the
highland industrial amateur-y without
peruillilut; itltill'lll'itli amnion. ‘
Snob ii untlounl incorporation lily!
trill he optioned. llrttl. by those who be-
lieve llinl trill-nit should be completely
brunt-n tip and their property destroyed.
it will be itpptmlld. «wood. by ttiolte
wlin doubt the eonxtitntiounlltr of Hitch
federzii lttenrporutloti hull. even if lt iii
rlitld. nbjm‘i to u us too great federal;
eeulmllzullon. it will be opposed.
third. by than: who will intllltt that it
inert.- volimlury lucorwrutlon like this
will not uttriii-t to tilt met-plume the
worm oi the hammers itzttittttl the un-
_ rl-lrust Nlultile uhd who will therefore
propose illfllt'ltd of it a nyntem or com-
pulsory bonuses for all federal corpo-
rations matured in interstate business.
Objoctlom For-untied.
Let on i-ouidder these objection: it!
”Mr older. The government hi now
trying; to dist-intro «nine 0! than. com.
tlilltliitiltil. unit it is not the intention
u! the trovet‘nltietti to ileitlst in the
least degree in its i-n'orl to end thou
t‘nliihiliiiiltllll whit-it tire tnduy monop<
”lining the eutntuert-e of this country.
inn ll ht not unit should not be the
pulley of the Rult'l‘lllllf‘ili to prevent
reusonuhio eoneenlrutlon of capital
whit-h to tleeeetsury to the wonomic
tit-veloptm-ul ot ltltltlufuellire. trade
null t‘ttiitiltt'i‘t‘t', it we. would maintain
uttr prt-iteltl bilvitiesu unprelnttt-y we
should tzlve to itidtwiriui rout-emu ill]
nptmrii'ltllt it) reitl‘tzdtiize dull in eon»
reutrnte their legitimate t-upilnl hi it
ederui enrporn lion
Swami. tin-ti- um those who doubt
the eotuttlitttlnmillty n! tint-h l'ederltl
incorporation The repulzttioti of utter
state and foreign common-e ix eorlrtlte
l_v totilelted iii the littlest menstire
upon t‘t‘ilL’l't‘KlI. itiitl l! (or the purpose
nl Kt‘t'lil‘iltfl in the tonal timrntmb innit»
tier tliut itittil iti' rogulutlou culture“
“in" inizlitt lliut ‘It only provide and
outltorite eertnln iitzeuries to carry on
that unlimierre it would min to be
wilhtn its power. This butt been ditt-
riliellr ittiirntet’i with moment to rail-
ruutl votnpsulm doing an Intermitt-
iiusiueioi rind intemuie lithium The
power ul llieorporullun hint been ex-
Pl‘l'ifil‘ti by t'flllfii‘t‘s! ltlitl unlit-ill by "W
supreme court in this regard Why.
then. with impact in any other form
.ol lull-mule t'llltlltllt‘m. like the null-
or umpilt ammo mite Mundurtm and
lllilt {prelim eotmneree. tint" the some
‘ power not he asserted?
Even those who are willing to row ,
mile dull the supreme court may uni»i
tziin nurb rodent] inmniorut‘ioti are in.
elilted to tiltpmw it on the ground of
its: tendency to the enlnrui-uielit of the
ledernl power it! the etpelule of the
power at the Staten. it is it lttmcil‘lti
:itutwer to thin argument to my that
no other method L‘tltt he suggested
whit-ii offeri- federal proleetion on the
one hand null eluee tulertil izinwrvllloti
on the other «it liiene grout ormnlna-
tintiw’lhul me ill “I” lt-deriti tremble
they "N in- wide ill the rotlntry and
tire entirely unlimited lti their bttttlnm
by stute lineal Nor is the eenlrnllla-
lion ol federal power nutter tltll net
likely to he I'KI‘I‘Illit‘t". Only the turnout
("(li'llttl'flnlln‘ would avail themselves of
turn it bur. heeuune the burden or
Ponipleie federal supervision and con
trot thlti tun-ti eertlliulv be iltiposed tit
ureontplluti the [lllfilllttt‘ of the lumr:
« portltiou would not he awarded by In
t ordinary innllttelut l'ltllf‘t'i‘fl,
The third (tiljt‘t'tittlt. ititit the wot-ill
Wonders will not nevi-pt federal in-
eorporutlou. is ensitt ullllwvl’t‘t‘. The
deem-mi ul illJmtt‘lititi rmrently adopted
in pmtteeutloutt under the llatitrttiti
new tire on. ttiomtllth uttd numbing
that the corporation: nth-cud by them
Intro hilt three room-it before them:
First. they tutu-l mauve thrill-ulna
into thotr twitupouettl part! in the «till
iereut nittlt‘it. with it mtmtttepi kiln to
iittflllltt‘th‘lm or capital .lttlti vitiioiiw tir-
iriltitxntien and to the country iii roar
trutitrutetl ontvrti)‘ ltllli enterpl‘ttie: or.
Hittt‘ltltti. iti doiinuee oi tow and till-
der mute newt irintt they ltttltti lb
lamp: to continue their itiltiiitm lll vto
lotion lit the totterul uzutule and thou
itlt‘ilt’ the petltlltleti of t’ltitMillllt and
bring on till luevttulile erluiluul prune
eutiun or tillt littllvldmthi hunted In the
tlt‘l‘t't‘l' it till 'lltttir “amplifier.
'l'ttlritn thwmmwwmnnm trod tic-
wpt iii good faith the brim) ehitrler .l
without.
Lima uw_Uitr.umury.
A letturul eotuptlhiorv tleotnie itl‘l‘t‘,
tit-mt no it Iubnltthiv rum tottottu th.
enriuu-iilluu low. in utiltetetuutl‘y within
to. remit illlit iiiiitl oi; jgtll‘tlttl‘tflitllt
width. by virtue of the l'ttltlltlltrutlotul
tliim)‘ ndviiueeu. will illit! titlrimlinte
t-oltiutul'ily or litt‘ifll'ttl‘ttlii‘lilmt tutv.
Witiitt the other "tilt" «diminution not
but unintv tiltv throughout! not need
in» import-l on or this l‘tttlltllliltm of it
mom “(‘0th and humid only helm»
ttwtuuurttr Itiit’di‘ltttt" thump.
The interim Wilttl'iti. tit my intuition.
lion. tutti limited .. t'eitivrul incorpora-
tion hill. tittllltttti‘ltltt the views t littflt
attempted to trot with. ~
‘ Windmill; ”MET.
’t‘llli Willi! W. Jail. l. mu
1919.
sections when any ci'iaie‘ltt oommitted
and it it; neutrino!" to have. it deputy
sheriff immediately. Bherii! Huwloy
hail received no written notieeu that.
the robtltolt will be abolished and he
may; that such notice will have to be
given before the present. contracts can
be abrogated.
My...
v—ltohl itch! itch! -- Scratch!
{Scrntohl Scratch! The more you
scratch the Worse the itch. Try Dunn's
lintment. it cures piles. eczema. uny
Ikin itching, All druggists sell in.
' W
’Foun-mcn onus FOR CONNECTI.
cut
The Secretary of the Navy hint
gunned an order providing for the dltr
trihutiou among the naval militia ot‘
the various Staten oi" tour-innit gunu,
ioqlltppod with Morris tubes. tor in-
,structlng the members oi the naval
militia in the title of these guns. The
lrecruitittg officers in the various di'sv
,tricts will he directed to inmruut the
‘ militiamen in the use of the guns. and
in new target manual is now being pre-
ipared by the department tor the. naval
militia organizations.
Under the regulations; adopted by
the department, (toutieetleut in en«
titledto two of tlteso guns, one for
E Hartford and one. for'New Haven. pro-
vided it. réquiaitlou is made by the
, State government. ,
...... .. ‘mwm... M..- .. .MWW ....“
GOLD MEDAL noun
i .....- .-.
l
i
...... “..., . d. - ... ”...—-.-...”
noun“
it
Cedar St, Valley St. and Stuart Ave.
J
,l Sewer Assessments.
Notice is hereby given that a hearing
will tulle place in the. City (‘ouneil
t‘lixtmber mount on littvlluud street.
‘tou Mouduy. February 7. .lliitl, at it p.
in. on the following proposed sewer
nouns-inherits ,
Ebenezer Hill, Sarah 1.; Hell
i den ...................... i tilti’?
lliiimbeth Meeker ........... tiltitl
; Margaret Novels ............ . 3.7.432
ilteltect‘a T. Mathews . ... .... 39.34
illelietreu T. Matthews ........ 92.05
liteuttiii Ilot‘an. Katie HORN!” him
{Elizabeth iroluud ........... 47,20
livron (‘. Mend ............. . 219.34
John Drhscoll ............... 102.66
lint. James J. Powers ....... ”(35.20
itose Knitting: ............... 70.33
i’utrlek ltueltiey ............ 59.87
Katherine (,loldrn ........... 59.79
‘ 'l‘otsil ..................... 31,212.23
3 Stilliil Norwttllt. Conn. Jun. 5th. 19m.
1 Alli-st:
John J. CUNEO.
jtt 3t City Clerk.
.... ......
"ninth! Notice
120'”! .
Semi-Annual Dividend
OF
The Norwalk Savings
Society
Xokulk. Conn. Dec. ill. 1th9.
Al u meeting (it the Directors oi
this Society. held this tiny, ll dividend
.ti the rule 0! FOUR it) per cont. per
:iununt \vuu declared to depositors
from the ouruhtipi oi the six months
ending lieeetnbor 3t. 1909.
The month Will he. (inlet-ell no pun»
bonito tutti paid on iind utter January
to. iilltl.
tly order oi lilo Board or Dirootorti.
FREDERICK A. ELLE.
'l‘rounrer
tits 1M
. owner twp an“...
wDividend Noticew
The South Not-welt Savings Bank
South Normllt. Conn.
hi it meeting of the director! of thin
intuit hold thin titty. a dividend It the
rule ot four per cont. por nnnum was
tluoliiroii to deiioaitorii from the writ.
hunt or the nix months uniting boo.
:tl. unto. The auto will be natural! on
”WM and will on and “tar Jan.
til. ii 0. «
by. order oi. inadmiml oL
‘ GEORGE b. W003)
'i‘maror.
Duo. 20, 31M. . i
i .i1 {£30410
‘riié iso‘nti Noiuilk
millionth!
south .Nouiwiiut. QONN.
The Trustees have ordered that in»
il-reitt‘ot the ruin til 4% per uuuum
be credited tttdt‘poflilot‘tl hi the auto
iiiu Department. for the would at:
touuiiu‘ooutnt llt‘t‘t‘ltlhel‘ ltitlt. tutti,
parable uu tutti uttgr Juliuarr tlttlt.
rectors.
Mt);
I
Norwalk Chronicler