Uncorrected OCR text from the Internet Archive scan — expect misread words and stray characters. Check the original scan before quoting.
by the letters missive, but did not attend the meeting.
The former from ill health, the latter from other reasons.
In November of the same year Nathaniel L. Hill' and
Maria his wife brought letters of dismission from the
mother church. He, with William Richards, were ap-
pointed the first deasons of the church, Nov. 27, 1832.
To their number were added Jesse B. Scribner, Oliver
Burr and Charles Jesup, who constituted the first pru-
dential committee. Rev. C. A. Boardman was the first
pastor of the church. He had supplied the pulpit for
two months or more, and had rendered valuable assist-
ance in drafting a constitution and perfecting the organi-
zation of the church, before receiving and accepting the
call to settle as paster. He was installed by a council
February 5, 1833. Judging from the records and the
references which one still hears, the newly formed church
was very fortunate in the selection of its pastor. Mr.
Boardman was a man of rich spiritual endowments as
well as of good mental gifts. In 1836, after three short
years he resigned his pastorate to accept an appointment
as secretary and general agent of the Presbyterian Edu-
cational Society. It was with real reluctance that the
church acceded to his request for dismission. We see
and feel how precious were the ties which bound the
pastor and people together, in the tender words which
the parting called forth. The church put upon record
the following vote: "Resolved, That it is with feeling of
deep regret that we part with our beloved pastor. We
are constrained to do so solely by a sense of duty as
members of the Church of Christ universal." Mr. Board-
man's parting words were: "I am leaving a flock whose
uniform kindness and liberality have made a deep im-
pression on my heart."
From the first the society seemed to have heartily
concurred with the church, in the call of the minister
and in laboring for the prosperity of the newly espoused
cause. At the regular meeting of the Ecclesiastical So-
ciety, Lewis Raymond was chosen moderator, Levi T.
Downes secretary, and Samuel Jackson treasurer.
Among the other items of business at that first meeting
of the Society it was voted: "That the place for setting
up the notices for future meetings of the Society, be on
the oak near the Northwest corner of the meeting
house." The old oak tree still stands and does duty as
in years long past. The first parish committee consisted
of the well-known and highly respected gentlemen:
Ebenezer Jesup, Samuel B. Sherwood, Dan Taylor,
Samuel Avery, and Sullivan Moulton. Proper regard
for the music of the sanctuary must have early engaged
the attention of the Society's committee. The first musi-
cal instrument was introduced in 1836, when the Society
voted to pay L. T. Downs and Andrew Comstock $25
for the bass viol which they had purchased for the
Society. The story is that there was more or less con-
sternation among the older inhabitants at introducing
such profane instruments into the house of God. At one
of the early parish meetings it was voted to sell the slips
at auction to the highest bidder. This custom was con-
tinued for many years. We must see that buying bass
viols and paying the minister's salary ($700) required
funds, and the sale of the slips seemed to have been a
matter of prime importance. Casting our eyes over the
records, we find the following: "Voted, That the col-
lector call on those owing for pew rents for the payment
of their respective debts. Voted, To sell the seats for
cash. Voted, That the slips in the meeting house shall
hereafter be rented for cash to be paid down before the
meeting dissolve." Let us not say that the former days
were so much better than these, at least in the matter
of paying pew rents. "Voted, That Thomas Rowland
act as auctioneer." In fact, we may judge of the elo-
quence and persuasive powers of the men living in those
days by the frequency with which they were called to per-
form the important function of auctioneering off the
slips. Alva Gray, Henry Piatt, William H. Jesup, Oliver
Burr, William Comstock, Hezekiah Nichols, Thomas
F. Rowland, Ebenezer Disbrow, E. H. Taylor, John N.
Betts and others served their term in this important
capacity.
The ministry of Rev. Henry Benedict during twelve
years, from 1840 to 1852, was a fruitful one. Previous
to his coming the church had given calls to Rev. Joseph
Foote, Mr. Weed and Richard W. Dickinson, each of
whom had supplied the pulpit for a longer or shorter
period. Mr. Benedict was a man of noble parts, a good
preacher and beloved pastor. It was unfortunate that
during his long term of service he was never settled as
pastor and that the records for the time are so meagre.
During the third year of his ministry there was a
gracious revival and a large ingathering, twenty-nine
uniting with the church. Some now living look back
upon that date as the vear of their conversion and con-
fession of their faith in Christ. Rev. Joseph D. Strong
was ordained and installed pastor April 12, 1853. He
resigned to accept a call extended by a church in the
Sandwich Islands. The dismissing council put upon rec-
ord this resolution: "In parting with Brother Strong,
we can most cordially recommend him to his church over
which he has been called to settle, as an able and faithful
minister of the. gospel. We likewise and most heartily
sympathize with the church in this place in the loss of
their beloved pastor. There is evidence of commendable
promptness and unanimity on the part of the church
and society in extending a call to the Rev. Timothy
Atkinson, who was settled as the fourth pastor of the
church in 1856. His ministry of eight years was in many
ways distinguished. He was a man of rare scholarship
and of marked piety. Coincident with his coming there
was awakened new spiritual life in the church and a
revival followed. He was indefatigable in labors. Under
his inspiration the meeting house was enlarged. We
find the following minute, under date of April 7th, 1857:
"Voted, That Jonas H. Phelps, John N. Betts, Elnathan
Wheeler, Gershom B. Bradley and Morris Ketchum be
appointed a committee to enlarge this house by carrying
the pulpit back as by plan represented." Under Mr.
Atkinson's ministry, the Sunday School took on new
form and manifested new life. It was re-organized in
i860, at which time John N. Betts was chosen superin-
tendent, Elnathan Wheeler secretary and treasurer,
George C. Lees assistant superintendent, F. W. Jesup
and Edward Richards librarians, Messrs. Winton, Coley,
Burr, Miss Emma Jesup and Mary F. Atkinson were
appointed a library committee. It may be stated in this
connection that Mr. Betts during his term of service as
superintendent for twenty-five years, was absent but
seA'en Sundays during that time, and then not because
of illness or disinclination, but to attend and assist at
funerals of kindred or friends. This is almost an
unparalelled record of fidelity and immunity from phy-
sical ills. The closing years of Mr. Atkinson's service
here were during the disturbed and distressing times of
the rebellion. He took strong anti-slavery grounds. In
this his church very generally stood by him. He
preached patriotic sermons. One was printed and had
wide circulation in pamphlet form. He helped the
young men, a goodly number of whom went forth to the
war from this church. His wife's failing health compelled
us
him, in 1864, to resign his charge and seek, for her sake,
a more favorable climate. Sound in theology, spiritually
minded, strong intellectually, of fine literary tastes, he
commanded the respect of all who knew him.
Rev. A. J. Hettrick, the fifth pastor, was installed
on September 14th, 1865. He came a young man, fresh
from his theological studies, and full of zeal for the work.
The installation sermon was preached by Rev. Roswell
D. Hitchcock, D. D., afterward president of Union Theo-
logical Seminary. Mr. Hettrick had been trained in a
Presbyterian Seminary and licensed to preach by the
Presbytery of New York. But he was settled by a Con-
gregational Council and as a pastor of a Congregational
church. I find about this time inserted in the records,
whether facetiously or with serious intent I know not ;
certain action was taken by the Saugatuck Presbyterian
Church. With its variety of names, it is the only time
that the church is called Presbyterian. This church has
been always Congregational in its policy, declaring both
its autonomy and its fellowship with the churches of like
faith and order. Mr. Hettrick came not only as a young
man full of enthusiasm for the work, but at a most op-
portune time. The war was over. The men that had
survived had come home. The times were good. The
Union had been preserved. Right had triumphed. Peo-
ple were thankful. Churches were prosperous. I am
struck with the list of young men and women, as well
as those of middle age, who were ready and waiting for
some one to gather them into the church. Many who
are to-day the staunch supporters of the church came
into it during the ministry of Mr. Hettrick. At this time
the church building was enlarged, a room had been fitted
up in the basement for the uses of the Sunday School.
These quarters had never been satisfactory. They were
contracted, dark and damp. In November, 1865, the fol-
lowing was voted by the society: (1) That we gratefully
accept the sum of money which has been raised by the
ladies and friends of the Sunday School (a thousand dol-
lars, with the promise of an additional sum), and (2)
Voted, That H. R. Treadwell, M. L. Mason, John N.
Eetts, H. M. Coley, A. J. Hettrick, A. L. Winton and
E. W. Taylor be, and are hereby appointed, a committee
to erect a new room according to the plan proposed.
That plan resulted in the commodious Sunday School
and lecture room adjoining the rear of the church. It
has proven in every respect satisfactory and useful. In
94